What’s Trending in the World of Shoplifting?

Wouldn’t it be nice if the criminal world was as easy as Twitter? You could just go online and look at what’s trending and then take proactive steps to stem any potential losses. That would be great! Unfortunately, criminals, especially thieves rarely broadcast their intentions. It’s up to the loss prevention community and local law enforcement to share these trends amongst each other in order to combat shoplifting.

You may or may not be aware, but shoplifting is much more than just putting one item in your purse, or pockets. I routinely see individuals and groups operating some very sophisticated fraud schemes in order to remove product from the store. One of those trends that have become more and more prevalent over the past year has involved refund fraud. I had a very complex case that spanned several months that was more sophisticated than anything I had every come across in all my years conducting Loss Prevention Investigations.

The basic storyline is that a brick and mortar store front was employing individuals to target stores for small, high dollar merchandise. Once the product was stolen from one store, it would then be brought to a second store where a refund was given for the product in the form of store credit. That individual would then utilize that credit in order to purchase a high end electronic item. The item, along with the receipt was sold to the store front. This is where it takes a more complex turn.

The store owners would then arrive back at the store with the receipt and electronic item and ask to exchange it for other product. This was routinely conducted with footwear or apparel items. The store owners would conduct the exchange and, on most occasions, pay a difference in cash of anywhere between $10 and $20.

Over several days, the store owners would return to my store and refund each item that was purchased during that exchange transaction. Since the receipt showed they paid a cash balance, inattentive store personnel would always give them a full cash refund. Did I lose you?

Essentially, I was at a loss 5 times for the same product. First it was stolen. Second, I gave them a store credit for stolen goods. Third, the store credit was then spent. Fourth, the product the credit was spent on was exchanged for additional merchandise. Fifth, we gave them cash. It was incredible once it was all uncovered. This group has figured out a way to essentially launder stolen goods and with a few steps and some patience, get cash. All while keeping the appearance of a legitimate transaction. All told, our stores lost well over $100k to this scam.

It was an expensive lesson to learn, but it goes to show just how creative people can be when it comes to fraud. While this was the first time I had ever seen something of this complexity, I can assure you that in the next year, someone will come up with an even more complex method to defraud retailers.